by Rebecca · Last updated Aug 23, 2026
If it’s tiny, squishy, or something they might spot at the Scholastic Book Fair, there’s a good chance a middle schooler will want it.
I’ve learned that the best library prizes aren’t necessarily the most educational, useful, or impressive. They just need to feel like something a kid actually wants. These are the prizes I keep coming back to for library programs, good behavior, makerspace challenges, reading challenges, and those little moments when a student has earned something.
And yes, a lot of these come out of my own pocket. That makes me picky. I want a prize bin that stays interesting without eating my entire budget, and everything here is inexpensive enough to restock without a second thought.
One other thing I’ve learned: middle schoolers are a tough audience. A seventh grader who has decided the library isn’t cool is probably not going to be impressed by a sticker. Give them something they can open, squish, fidget with, trade, use, or show a friend? Now you’ve got their attention.
Contains Amazon affiliate links.
Blind bags turn a small prize into a whole little event. They get to open it, see which animal they got, and immediately start comparing with everyone else. These glow in the dark too, which gives them a second life at home long after the library moment is over. Saved on the B-Animal assortment.
A trophy makes a challenge actually feel like a challenge. I especially like these for makerspace winners or reading competitions where the prize should feel a little more special than something pulled from the bin. Gold cup on a black base, small enough to sit on a shelf at home.
Poppers and bubble-style fidgets in one box mean you don’t have to buy five different packs to keep your prize bin interesting. There are enough shapes and colors that students can actually choose. This listing sells several styles, and the link opens the Square set.
Completely ridiculous, and that’s exactly why they work. Give a kid one of these and watch it immediately become a tiny wave across the library.
The scents make these feel a little more interesting than the usual sticker sheet, which matters when your audience has decided stickers are for little kids. Enough different scents in the set that the same reward doesn’t get old by November.
These little animals move, wiggle, and double as a fidget. The assortment gives the bin plenty of variety without looking picked over.
Four colors in one pen makes this one useful, not just cute. These are the ones I expect students to actually use long after they leave the library.
These are made for trading, showing off, and immediately trying to land a trick on the nearest flat surface. Note that the pack contains the boards, not the ramps or accessories some listing photos show.
A fidget you can hand to a student during class without creating a new classroom distraction. Quiet, small, and easy to keep in a desk drawer.
Soft, slow-rising, and quiet enough that they won’t immediately become a projectile across the library. An easy crowd-pleaser.
Cheap enough to hand out generously, which is the whole point of a system like this. They work best when students can save them up and trade them for something from a separate prize bin.
These feel more substantial than most of the tiny trinkets here. I’d save them for challenge winners or students who have earned a higher-tier prize.
Small, cheap, and easy to hand out at the door. Especially handy when you need a prize that doesn’t require students to stop and make a selection.
Basically ordinary pens with a much more fun personality. The soft cartoon topper is what makes students reach past the plain pens in the bin.
Better for books, folders, laptops, and water bottles than as a traditional prize. An easy add-on to almost any reward.
These are a step up from the everyday bin item, so I’d hold them back for a smaller best-prizes tier rather than putting them out as the default grab.
These aren’t necessarily my favorite library prizes, but they work when you have a student who is determined to negotiate. Check your district’s wellness policy and allergy guidelines before handing out food, keep edible rewards separate from your regular prize bin, and don’t hand candy out unsupervised.
Individually wrapped with five flavors to choose from. Sometimes a Jolly Rancher is simply the prize that gets the biggest reaction.
A resealable bag makes these easy to store and dole out. The sour version feels just a little more middle school than ordinary candy.
Honestly, this one is less about student prizes and more about surviving the school day. Keep some for the front office, the teacher who covered your duty, and yourself.
What I’d actually do
If you’re starting a prize bin from scratch, don’t buy 500 of one thing. Buy a few different kinds of prizes instead. A bin with squishies, pens, fidgets, blind bags, stickers, and something completely ridiculous gives students a reason to look through it. Variety makes even inexpensive prizes feel more exciting.
And that’s really the trick: the prize doesn’t have to be valuable. It has to feel like a choice.
Most of these come in at just a few cents per student, which means a relatively small restock can carry you through months of reading challenges, makerspace competitions, library incentives, and all those spontaneous “you did something awesome, pick something” moments.
What I’m really buying isn’t plastic or stickers or tiny rubber hands. I’m buying that little moment when a kid who normally wouldn’t care suddenly says, “Wait, you have those?” Looking for more finds like this? Browse the rest of the Library & Education guides.
A few more worth considering
Cheap and popular, but expect them to end up on walls, windows, and probably one ceiling tile.
Shop →
Perfectly fine, but I’d spend a little more for the larger affirmation sticker assortment.
Shop →
A fun alternative to the mini spinners, but they do the same job and don’t add anything the smaller ones don’t.
Shop →More guides you might like
The bigger version of a prize that gets kids to stay.
For the challenge you are handing these prizes out for.
An interactive board that rewards participation.
Everything else the room needs.
